Disclosure. I build one of these apps, Stockist Map Sync. This page compares kinds of app, not named products, and says where a different kind would suit you better.
The three kinds of locator app
| Kind | Where the locations come from | Suits | Watch for |
|---|---|---|---|
| List-based | A list you keep inside the app, typed in or uploaded as a spreadsheet | Locations that are not in Shopify, such as your own shops | A second list to keep in step with reality |
| Google Maps based | Usually a list in the app, drawn on Google Maps | Stores that need Google features such as Street View or place data | You may have to set up an API key and a Google billing account |
| Synced from customers | Shopify customers carrying a tag you choose | Brands whose stockists are already wholesale customers in Shopify | Less useful if your locations are not customers |
List-based
You add each location in the app's own screen, or upload a spreadsheet. This is simple and works for any kind of location. The cost is upkeep: the list in the app is separate from everything else you run, so it only stays right if someone remembers to update it.
Google Maps based
The map is drawn with Google Maps. Shoppers know the look, and you get Google's extras. In return, some of these apps ask you to create a Google Cloud project, generate a Maps API key and attach a billing account, and usage beyond Google's allowance is billed to you by Google. Check what the app asks for before you install.
Synced from customers
The app reads the Shopify customers you tag and puts their addresses on the map. Update the customer and the map follows. This suits wholesale brands, because the stockist list already exists as customer records. It suits you less if your locations are not customers, although a good app of this kind also lets you add locations by hand or by CSV.
Five things to check
1. How the locations get in, and stay current
This is the biggest difference between apps. Ask where the data will live and who will update it. If your stockists are Shopify customers, syncing from tags means you update one place. If your locations live in a spreadsheet you trust, look for clean CSV import and a way to re-import changes. Avoid anything that makes location data a second job.
2. Whether it needs a Google Maps API key
Some apps need a key and a billing account. Others use open map data such as OpenStreetMap and need neither. Unless you need Google's own features, an app without a key is less to set up and has no usage bill from a third party.
3. How it fits your theme
Prefer an app that installs as a theme app block in the theme editor, so the map sits inside your page at your theme's width. A locator in a frame with its own fonts and colours looks bolted on.
4. Search and "near me"
The value of a locator is answering "where can I buy this near me?". Check that it searches by suburb, postcode or address and sorts results by distance. A map with markers and no search is a picture.
5. Pricing that matches your size
Many apps price by number of locations. Find out where the steps are and whether features are held back for higher plans. A free allowance lets you prove the app on your own store before you pay.
Which kind should you pick?
- Your stockists are Shopify customers: an app synced from customer tags is the least upkeep.
- Your locations live in a spreadsheet, not in Shopify: a list-based app, or any app with good CSV import and bulk editing.
- You need Google's own features: a Google Maps based app, accepting the key setup.
- You have a few fixed locations: you may not need an app. A simple page might do. See the where-to-buy page guide.
Where Stockist Map Sync fits
Stockist Map Sync is the third kind. Tag a customer in Shopify and their default address appears as a location on your map. Remove the tag and it goes. Here is how it answers the five checks:
- Data: synced from tagged customers, with webhooks and a nightly re-check. Other locations can be added by hand or by CSV, exported, edited in a spreadsheet and re-imported.
- API key: none. Map tiles are from OpenStreetMap.
- Theme fit: a map block added in the theme editor on Online Store 2.0 themes, with eleven map styles and your marker colour.
- Search: by suburb, postcode or stockist name with suggestions, plus a Use my location button, results sorted by distance within a search radius.
- Pricing: Free up to 25 locations, Pro US$9.99 a month up to 250, Business US$24.99 a month unlimited. Every feature is on every plan.
It is not the right choice if you need Google Maps itself. In that case choose a Google Maps based app.